Why Struggling in Math is Good!

In today’s society we can find answers at our finger tips.  With smartphone, tablets, laptops, WiFi, and other tools at our finger tips, we can quickly find out thing we need to know quickly.  This has created a society and a group of students that are not comfortable with struggling, at least in the sense of finding information.  Who remembers going to the library, using the card catalog to find a book to do research, then having to know the Dewey decimal system to find where the book was, then going into the stacks with a bunch of note cards and writing down the important information.  Today’s students can accomplish this feat in seconds using technology, they have become spoiled!

They want the same type of quick resolution in math, but when they can’t google a math problem or use Photomath to do it for them, they get frustrated.  Struggling to solve a math problem is a necessary evil in becoming a good mathematician!  It is the struggle that makes us recall all the tools that we have to solve problems.  One of my favorite things to do as a math teacher is to discuss with students the different ways of solving the same problem.  These are some of the best discussions in a math classroom, I love asking students why they chose a specific technique or a specific order in doing a problem.  It gets them verbalizing and thinking about mathematics in a different way.

When students are really stuck on a math problem I love to ask them to give me some type of  informal analysis of what is going on in the problem.  This can sometimes start us down the right path to the solution.  We have to teach students that informal analysis like sketching, making conjectures, and estimating is necessary when we first observe a problem.  Once we complete the informal analysis we can develop a plan how to transition from informal to formal, and create a need for certain computational skills and processes.  This is just part of what I enjoy about the design thinking behind most Desmos Activities (click here for more).

I also think it is important for students to be wrong in mathematics.  I don’t mean that they added wrong, or missed a negative sign, I mean did a problem completely wrong.  We learn from our mistakes, and in mathematics I think this is a great learning tool.  When we can have a dialogue and observe others solving a problem, especially one which we got wrong, we see a different perspective.  As I progressed through high school, college, and even now as a teacher; I have learned the importance of doing something wrong, and trying to avoid that from happening again.  NOBODY IS PERFECT!!  It frustrates me when students are upset about getting a 97% on a test, but they don’t want to ask why they got something wrong.  numerical percentage grade for me are a waste, and a hindrance.  When students stop being afraid of being wrong and losing points, that’s when we can learn.

This week we are giving the PARCC test in my school.  I am administering the test to my Algebra 1 students.   People have mentioned that the PARCC is too hard, and not fair.  Let me tell you what I have notice:

  • My students worked really hard!  Harder then I saw them work all year
  • My students struggled, going back and forth between the questions
  • My students had some great mathematical conversation when they were done the test
  • My students used a ton of different skills to solve the problem
  • My students weren’t afraid to be wrong and tried almost every problem
  • My students enjoyed being challenged!!!

Adversity is not a bad thing, we learn from it.  My students took a really challenging standardized test this week, and hopefully they learned from it.  I hope they learned that everything in life is not easy.  I hope they learned how smart they really are.  I hope they learned never to give up.  I hope they learn that struggling is a good thing!!


One thought on “Why Struggling in Math is Good!

  1. To do well in math a lot of patience and perseverance is needed. Someone who does well in math will exercise delayed gratification (rare I think in today’s society).

    I used to do teaching assistant work for calculus and statistics courses. I do recall being a TA for non-math science (some pre-med) students for an Intro. To Stats for Life Sciences. There were a few students who complained about a B+ and not getting an A/A+. I was tempted to say that math/stats courses are much more different than biology/chemistry health science courses. I kept my mouth shut.

    I do agree with your point of “When students stop being afraid of being wrong and losing points, that’s when we can learn.”. There are students who focus on just the grades only and not so much on learning. Due to this, there would be cases of people having credentials but not the (expected) ability to back it up.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s